Strengthening our bond to improve animals' lives

Petition against Garmin's Shock Collar

American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior Forums Members Members General Discussion Petition against Garmin's Shock Collar

This topic contains 0 replies, has 1 voice, and was last updated by avsabe@gmail.com avsabe@gmail.com 1 year, 5 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #9760
    avsabe@gmail.com
    avsabe@gmail.com
    Keymaster

    From the AVSAB email, we received the following request to sign a petition against the new Garmin shock collar that is controlled by a smart phone:

    On September 8, Garmin announced its new Delta Smart – Smartphone-Based Dog Activity Tracker and Trainer, which includes an electric shock feature. Like playing Pokemon Go, dog owners will be able to send jolts of electricity to their dogs necks with just a tap on their smartphone screen.
    When Garmin posted a video on Facebook that day, thousands of people were outraged. “Your dog wasn’t born with manners,” Garmin wrote. “Our new Delta Smart dog training device and activity tracker words with your smartphone to help keep your dog safe, healthy, and well behaved.” The video received so many scathing responses that Garmin blocked many of the commenters on Facebook.

    launched a petition on Change.org on Friday asking Garmin to remove the electric-shock feature from the product. As I write to you, we have nearly 4,500 signatures. Whether Garmin responds or not, the word is spreading that shock collars are dangerous. So I call that a win.
    As you can see below, I included information from your position statement on the petition. Would you consider sending a link to the petition to AVSAB members?
    Thanks for your consideration,
    Remove the electric shock feature from Garmin’s new Delta Smart Dog System
     
    We ask that Garmin remove the electric shock feature from the Delta Smart Dog device. GPS is a wonderful tool to use with our dogs, and so we love that Garmin has created a system for the pups. But the shock component is too cruel and too dangerous.

    The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB), the Pet Professional Guild, and The  UK Kennel Club, have all spoken out against the use of electric shock collars — which are banned in countries including Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Austria, and Switzerland, and in some Australian states.

    AVSAB explains that using aversives such as electric shock to train dogs can lead to “potential adverse effects, which include but are not limited to: inhibition of learning, increased fear-related and aggressive behaviors, and injury to animals and people interacting with animals.”

    With all training, timing is important, but when using an aversive tool like a shock collar, timing is essential. In order for a dog to learn what to do and what not to do, trainers must time the shock precisely when the dog does the behavior. If not, the dog will associate that punishment with something else.

    For example: A woman wants her dog Bowser to learn to not jump on the couch. Bowser trots into the family room, jumps up on the couch, and climbs into her daughter’s lap — at which point the electric shock hits him. She has now put her child in serious danger. Bowser will not associate the act of jumping up on the couch with the pain; he will associate her child with the pain and could very well become aggressive toward her.

    In addition, proponents of shock collars will explain that the “zap” does not hurt the dog — that it’s the same feeling as a little static electricity jolt from touching the TV while standing on carpet. That jolt might not bother humans, but what is missing from this argument is the fact that aversive methods only work if they scare and/or hurt the dog. If the zap doesn’t bother the dog, then the dog will not learn. Electric shock collars do hurt and scare dogs. If they didn’t, no one would use them.

    Garmin is a highly regarded name, and unwitting customers might assume the Delta Smart Dog activity tracker is safe because your name is on it. It is not. Please do the right thing for the dogs and their people and remove the shock feature from the device.


    Carolyn Lincoln, DVM
    AVSAB Corresponding Secretary

    Carolyn Lincoln, DVM
    AVSAB Corresponding Secretary

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Contact us

For any questions, please contact

Carolyn Lincoln, DVM
AVSAB Corresponding Secretary
avsabe@gmail.com

Find us on facebook, twitter and youtube!